France’s $9 Billion Blunder that gave Paris to Germany
This week in Live, Learn, History: Battle for France
This week marks the 80th anniversary of the Allies liberating Paris. Prior to the liberation, Parisian’s lived under the control of Hitler and the Nazis for just over 4 years.
France spent billions to prevent such an event from happening but it couldn’t stop the significant advancements in military technology and the daring tactics of the German war machine.
After World War I, France was determined to never suffer the kind of devastating invasion it had endured during that brutal conflict. The French military leaders believed that the best way to protect their country was to build an enormous line of fortifications along the border with Germany. This line became known as the Maginot Line, named after André Maginot, the French Minister of War who championed its construction.
Begun in the late 1920s and completed in the 1930s, the Maginot Line was a marvel of engineering. It stretched over 450 miles along France’s eastern border, from Switzerland in the south to Luxembourg in the north, costing between 5 to 7 billion francs to complete (about $6 to $9 billion US dollars today although an exact number is hard to find but most fall within this range).
The Maginot Line was packed with underground bunkers, artillery emplacements, machine gun nests, and living quarters for troops. Some of the fortifications were so advanced that they had underground railways to transport troops and supplies!
The largest of the forts could hold 1,000 soldiers and were considered virtually impenetrable.
These fortifications were designed to protect France from any future German invasion. They had thick concrete walls, retractable gun turrets, and were equipped with state-of-the-art technology of the time.
The French military believed that the Maginot Line would force any potential invader to either confront this heavily fortified barrier or divert their forces into other, less defensible terrain, giving France the advantage.
The Maginot Line was brilliant in concept—but there was a critical flaw in its design: it didn’t extend across the entire French border.
The French, trusting that the Ardennes Forest to the north was too dense and difficult to move large forces through, did not fully extend the line there, leaving the area weakly defended.
They believed that any German attack would be funneled into Belgium, giving France time to respond.
But as history shows, the Germans, under the leadership of Adolf Hitler and his clever generals, did the unexpected. Instead of attacking head-on through the Maginot Line, they bypassed it entirely!
In May 1940, they invaded France through Belgium and the Ardennes Forest—where the French had left their defenses relatively thin.
The Germans blitzed through this supposedly impassable terrain with tanks, motorized infantry, and air support, catching the French and their allies completely by surprise.
338,000 British and French troops were evacuated from the beaches of Dunkirk in Operation Dynamo between May 26 and June 4, 1940.
Within weeks, German forces were well behind the Maginot Line, rendering it almost useless in the fight. The French troops stationed along the line were stuck in their fortresses, unable to engage the enemy effectively, as the Germans swept around them.
The French had put too much faith in static defenses, not anticipating the speed and agility of modern mechanized warfare.
On June 14, 1940, the German army entered Paris. The once bustling, lively streets of the city were now eerily quiet. The French people watched in disbelief and sadness as the Nazi soldiers marched through their beloved city.
The swastika, the symbol of Nazi power, was raised over the Eiffel Tower, and Nazi flags hung from buildings. It was a dark day for France and for the world.
For four long years, Paris remained under Nazi control. But in 1944, after D-Day—the famous Allied invasion of Normandy—the tide began to turn.
Slowly but surely, the Allied forces pushed the Germans back, and by August of that year, they reached the outskirts of Paris.
On August 19, the French Resistance in Paris rose up against the Germans. It was a risky move, but they fought with all their heart. Meanwhile, General de Gaulle, leading the Free French forces, and the American troops moved in.
On August 25, 1944, the Germans surrendered, and Paris was finally liberated!
Despite its failure in World War II, the Maginot Line remained intact in many areas and became a symbol of both French ingenuity and the dangers of relying too heavily on one strategy.
Today, parts of the Maginot Line still stand, a reminder of how even the best-laid plans can be outflanked by innovation and surprise.
The Heroes
The French Soldiers of the Maginot Line
Although the Maginot Line was bypassed, the soldiers stationed along it showed remarkable courage. They were stuck in their fortifications as the German forces swept around them, but rather than surrendering immediately, many units held out for days and weeks, refusing to give up their posts.
In some cases, isolated forts continued to resist German attacks even after France had officially fallen. Their determination and discipline were heroic, even when the situation seemed hopeless.
Charles de Gaulle
One of the most significant heroes of this period was Charles de Gaulle, a French military officer who refused to accept defeat after the German invasion.
When the French government signed an armistice with the Germans, de Gaulle fled to Britain, where he made his famous appeal to the French people on June 18, 1940. From London, he broadcast over the BBC, urging the French to continue resisting the Germans and vowing to fight for France’s freedom.
De Gaulle became the leader of the Free French Forces, and his message of hope inspired countless French people to join the resistance. He would later become a pivotal figure in the liberation of France.
The French Resistance
Though the formal army was defeated, the French Resistance rose up in defiance. The network was made up of ordinary men and women who carried out acts of sabotage against the German occupiers.
They derailed trains, destroyed communication lines, gathered intelligence for the Allies, and even assassinated key German officials.
Heroes like Jean Moulin, who unified various Resistance groups under de Gaulle’s leadership, and Lucie Aubrac, who helped free her husband and other resistance fighters from German custody, risked their lives in the face of brutal repression.
Many were captured, tortured, or executed, but their courage in fighting back under such dangerous conditions made them legendary.
Captain Pierre Armand Leclerc
An unsung hero, Captain Pierre Armand Leclerc, was one of the defenders of the Maginot Line. Leclerc and his men held their fort, Fort de Schoenenbourg, even after they were cut off from the rest of France.
Isolated, surrounded, and under constant attack, Leclerc’s forces endured heavy bombardment but continued to resist. Only after France officially surrendered did they agree to cease fighting. Their courage under siege was a testament to the fighting spirit of the French soldiers.
Paul Reynaud
Paul Reynaud was the French Prime Minister at the time of the German invasion. He refused to give in to defeat and argued against signing the armistice with the Germans, even when other leaders, like Marshal Pétain, were ready to accept it.
Though Reynaud was eventually forced to step down and was arrested by the Vichy government, his refusal to capitulate and his desire to continue the fight made him a hero for those who believed in a free France.
Where to visit to learn more
Maginot Line Fortifications
You can visit several restored forts that were part of the famous Maginot Line. Popular sites include:
Fort Hackenberg (Veckring): This is one of the largest forts in the Maginot Line and offers guided tours, allowing visitors to see underground tunnels, armory, and bunkers.
Fort Schoenenbourg (Alsace): A well-preserved fort with an impressive network of tunnels and exhibits detailing the history of the Maginot Line.
Fort Fermont (Longuyon): Another large site with original equipment and interactive exhibits.
Dunkirk
The Dunkirk 1940 Museum offers detailed exhibits on the German advance and the events leading up to the Fall of France.
Paris
Musée de l’Armée (Les Invalides): Located in central Paris, this military museum covers France’s military history, including World War II and the German occupation. There are extensive displays on the Fall of France in 1940, as well as personal stories and artifacts.
Le Musée de la Libération de Paris: This museum focuses on the German occupation and the liberation of Paris in 1944, but it also gives context to the invasion and occupation of the city in 1940.
Sedan
Château de Sedan: This medieval fortress became important during the German invasion in 1940 when German forces outflanked the Maginot Line. The museum at the fortress offers insights into the military tactics used during the invasion.
If your family vacations involve visiting historical places, you should subscribe to our weekly newsletter. Each week we’ll highlight historical events and the places you should visit to learn more about them.
Family travel is all about building lasting memories together. We’ve enjoyed exploring parks, historical places, and new cultures. Having these shared experiences has brought us all closer.
As we’ve explored, we’ve enjoyed keeping track of the countries, US states, and cities we’ve visited.
With our experiences over the years, we decided to build an app to help us keep track of our adventures. It’s a digital scrapbook of our travel memories.
We’ve made the app available for other families to use. It’s currently available for free (for life) to those who join our Founding Families. If you’re interested, we’d love to have you join us.